Structure

Tail coproducts in extensive categories

In Set\Set, the tails {β∣α≤β<κ}\{ \beta \mid \alpha \leq \beta < \kappa \} of a cardinal κ\kappa have empty intersection. We show that the analogous statement holds in every infinitary extensive category, and for κ=ℵ0\kappa = \aleph_0 in every countably extensive category.

Lemma.

Let κ\kappa be an infinite cardinal, and let C\C be an infinitary extensive category, or a countably extensive category if κ=ℵ0\kappa = \aleph_0. Let TT be an object, and let TβT_\beta be the summand with index β\beta of the coproduct ∐β<κT\coprod_{\beta < \kappa} T. For α<κ\alpha < \kappa, let D(α)≔∐α≤β<κTβ.\textstyle D(\alpha) \coloneqq \coprod_{\alpha \leq \beta < \kappa} T_\beta. Then the canonical morphisms D(α′)→D(α)D(\alpha') \to D(\alpha) for α≤α′\alpha \leq \alpha' form a diagram D:(κ,≥)→CD : (\kappa,\geq) \to \C. If DD has a limit, then it is an initial object.

Proof. Recall that the initial object 00 is strict (see here), i.e. every morphism A→0A \to 0 is an isomorphism. Since coproducts are disjoint, coproduct inclusions are monomorphisms, so that we may treat them as inclusions of subobjects. In particular, D(α)D(\alpha) is a subobject of D(0)D(0), which is a coproduct of D(α)D(\alpha) and ∐β<αTβ\coprod_{\beta < \alpha} T_\beta. Moreover, the limit LL of DD is the intersection ⋂α<κD(α)\bigcap_{\alpha < \kappa} D(\alpha) of subobjects of D(0)D(0).

Since coproducts are stable under pullbacks, we have L≅∐β<κ(L∩Tβ)L \cong \coprod_{\beta < \kappa} (L \cap T_\beta). Since a coproduct of initial objects is initial, it suffices to show that L∩Tβ≅0L \cap T_\beta \cong 0 for every β<κ\beta < \kappa. Since D(0)D(0) is a coproduct of D(β+1)D(\beta + 1) and ∐γ≤βTγ\coprod_{\gamma \leq \beta} T_\gamma, and coproducts are disjoint, the intersection of these two subobjects is 00. Since L⊆D(β+1)L \subseteq D(\beta + 1) and Tβ⊆∐γ≤βTγT_\beta \subseteq \coprod_{\gamma \leq \beta} T_\gamma, it follows that L∩TβL \cap T_\beta admits a morphism to 00, so that L∩Tβ≅0L \cap T_\beta \cong 0 by strictness. □\square

Context

This page is referenced by the following category implications.